TY - JOUR
T1 - Advancing electrochemical impedance analysis through innovations in the distribution of relaxation times method
AU - Maradesa, Adeleke
AU - Py, Baptiste
AU - Huang, Jake
AU - Lu, Yang
AU - Iurilli, Pietro
AU - Mroziński, Aleksander
AU - Law, Ho Mei
AU - Wang, Yuhao
AU - Wang, Zilong
AU - Li, Jingwei
AU - Xu, Shengjun
AU - Meyer, Quentin
AU - Liu, Jiapeng
AU - Brivio, Claudio
AU - Gavrilyuk, Alexander
AU - Kobayashi, Kiyoshi
AU - Bertei, Antonio
AU - Williams, Nicholas J.
AU - Zhao, Chuan
AU - Danzer, Michael
AU - Žic, Mark
AU - Wu, Phillip
AU - Yrjänä, Ville
AU - Pereverzyev, Sergei
AU - Chen, Yuhui
AU - Weber, André
AU - Kalinin, Sergei V.
AU - Schmidt, Jan Philipp
AU - Tsur, Yoed
AU - Boukamp, Bernard A.
AU - Zhang, Qiang
AU - Gaberšček, Miran
AU - O'Hayre, Ryan
AU - Ciucci, Francesco
PY - 2024/7/17
Y1 - 2024/7/17
N2 - Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is widely used in electrochemistry, energy sciences, biology, and beyond. Analyzing EIS data is crucial, but it often poses challenges because of the numerous possible equivalent circuit models, the need for accurate analytical models, the difficulties of nonlinear regression, and the necessity of managing large datasets within a unified framework. To overcome these challenges, non-parametric models, such as the distribution of relaxation times (DRT, also known as the distribution function of relaxation times, DFRT), have emerged as promising tools for EIS analysis. For example, the DRT can be used to generate equivalent circuit models, initialize regression parameters, provide a time-domain representation of EIS spectra, and identify electrochemical processes. However, mastering the DRT method poses challenges as it requires mathematical and programming proficiency, which may extend beyond experimentalists’ usual expertise. Post-inversion analysis of DRT data can be difficult, especially in accurately identifying electrochemical processes, leading to results that may not always meet expectations. This article examines non-parametric EIS analysis methods, outlining their strengths and limitations from theoretical, computational, and end-user perspectives, and provides guidelines for their future development. Moreover, insights from survey data emphasize the need to develop a large impedance database, akin to an impedance genome. In turn, software development should target one-click, fully automated DRT analysis for multidimensional EIS spectra interpretation, software validation, and reliability. Particularly, creating a collaborative ecosystem hinged on free software could promote innovation and catalyze the adoption of the DRT method throughout all fields that use impedance data.
AB - Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is widely used in electrochemistry, energy sciences, biology, and beyond. Analyzing EIS data is crucial, but it often poses challenges because of the numerous possible equivalent circuit models, the need for accurate analytical models, the difficulties of nonlinear regression, and the necessity of managing large datasets within a unified framework. To overcome these challenges, non-parametric models, such as the distribution of relaxation times (DRT, also known as the distribution function of relaxation times, DFRT), have emerged as promising tools for EIS analysis. For example, the DRT can be used to generate equivalent circuit models, initialize regression parameters, provide a time-domain representation of EIS spectra, and identify electrochemical processes. However, mastering the DRT method poses challenges as it requires mathematical and programming proficiency, which may extend beyond experimentalists’ usual expertise. Post-inversion analysis of DRT data can be difficult, especially in accurately identifying electrochemical processes, leading to results that may not always meet expectations. This article examines non-parametric EIS analysis methods, outlining their strengths and limitations from theoretical, computational, and end-user perspectives, and provides guidelines for their future development. Moreover, insights from survey data emphasize the need to develop a large impedance database, akin to an impedance genome. In turn, software development should target one-click, fully automated DRT analysis for multidimensional EIS spectra interpretation, software validation, and reliability. Particularly, creating a collaborative ecosystem hinged on free software could promote innovation and catalyze the adoption of the DRT method throughout all fields that use impedance data.
KW - distribution of relaxation times
KW - electrochemical impedance spectroscopy
KW - methods development
KW - inverse problems
KW - electrochemical systems
UR - https://github.com/ciuccislab/ DRT-Survey
U2 - 10.1016/j.joule.2024.05.008
DO - 10.1016/j.joule.2024.05.008
M3 - Review Article or Literature Review
SN - 2542-4351
VL - 8
SP - 1958
EP - 1981
JO - Joule
JF - Joule
IS - 7
ER -