False confession to robbery: the roles of suggestibility, anxiety, memory disturbance and withdrawal symptoms

A1 Journal article (refereed)


Internal Authors/Editors


Publication Details

List of Authors: Santtila P, Alkiora P, Ekholm M, Niemi P
Publisher: ROUTLEDGE
Publication year: 1999
Journal: JOURNAL OF FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY
Journal acronym: J FORENSIC PSYCHIATR
Volume number: 10
Issue number: 2
Start page: 399
End page: 415
Number of pages: 17
ISSN: 0958-5184


Abstract

This article describes a case of a post-office robbery in which two validated false confessions were made. A young man, Mr S, made a detailed confession to the actual robbery whereas his partner, Ms A, confessed to having been present when Mr S and his accomplice left to carry out the robbery as well as to hearing Mr S confess to the robbery. Both of these confessions later turned out to be false. Mr S's confession had the hallmarks of a coerced-internalized false confession, compared with Ms As, which was more likely a coerced-compliant false confession. The individual and situational factors that probably contributed to these false confessions are described. Mr S had high suggestibility, low memory ability, and high anxiety. Ms A did not have these vulnerabilities. Both had been drinking alcohol and using drugs for an extended period of time, thus resulting in relative lack of memory for the day of the robbery as well as withdrawal symptoms while incarcerated which may have contributed to the confessions. Aspects of Mr S's confession that pointed to its unreliability are also described.


Keywords

coerced-compliant, coerced-internalized, drug withdrawal, false confession, interrogative suggestibility, memory disturbance

Last updated on 2019-19-10 at 02:58